Maybelline Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara

Maybelline Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara
I tried my best with Clarins Be Long Mascara – with the most perfect, slightly angled, brush head wand that got right into the corners, the non clumpy application that transformed stumpy lashes into something more substantial and an intense dark brown shade – it ticked all the boxes, apart from the most important one – it flakes (very badly indeed) after a couple of hours. I went through three of them and the same thing happened each time. A sure sign that it was time to move on.

Maybelline’s Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara does seem to be the complete opposite to Be Long, a quarter of the price for a start. The brush is huge and spiky and the mascara is a fairly ‘wet’ formulation with a faint scent of bluebells (although some people think it’s more of a rose scent).

Do for lashes what stilettos do for legs. Our polymer enriched formula coats each lash.

 New Stretch & Set brush, with unique criss-cross bristles, firmly grasps lashes. Contact lens safe.

I always choose brown mascara. The brown shade is more mid brown than dark brown. The shades (if you can find them), appear to be Brown, Blackish Brown and Very Black (with waterproof formulas too).  I wish I could wear black mascara to ‘pop’ my eyes, I love the look of dark eyebrows and lashes with blonde hair, but on me, it always looks too harsh and ageing. I’m being reverse ageist here, but I really think dark, sooty eyes are best suited to younger skin.

This mascara doesn’t volumise and because of the brush size, it can be quite tricky to get into the inner corners of your eyes. But what it does do, is lengthen the sparsest of lashes, separates them and, this is the biggie, IT DOESN’T FLAKE!

Removal is easy, I use Liz Earle Cleanse & Polish to remove my eye make up and this one just melts away under the cream.


This mascara adds LENGTH not necessarily volume (volume mascaras = thick goopy spider legs in my opinion). The length looks beautiful and natural, just short of what false lashes give! I’m serious. It also doesn’t flake off over the day.

This is some of the best mascara I have ever used. It lengthens, defines, doesn’t clump, doesn’t have that gummy texture that a lot of mascaras have, dries quickly, washes easily, and you don’t pay a high price. I will buy this as long as they keep making it – I so hope they never discontinue it.

The pigmentation is great and the formula is the perfect consistency, not too thick, not too watery. It isn’t flaky and lasts all day. The brush is great for making lashes look long and lush (not good for thickening). I typically use this as a finishing coat over 2-3 coats of volumising mascara so I get length and volume together.

For a drug store mascara it really does a good job of defining and separating my lashes. I love the brush, though the sharp poky bristles might not be everyone’s cup of tea. I do stray away to other mascaras, but I always have one of these in my makeup drawer waiting.

This is a good mascara if you have short lashes because it does gives length. Not really much volume. If you want a subtle, daytime, and lengthy look, this mascara is good. Doesnt clump and nice brush too, separates lashes. I like lots of volume more than length, so this mascara wasn’t really for me.


You will love (or loathe) this mascara depending on kind of lashes you have and the effect you want to achieve. The negative reviews say the same thing, that the mascara creates a spidery effect and that its wet consistency can smudge upon application and leave traces on the upper eyelid.

I tend to agree to some extent, I always use the ‘stem’ part of a cotton wool bud to wipe away excess product – it helps that Lash Stiletto is quite cheap, would I do that to a £20+ mascara? Probably not. The ‘spidery’ effect doesn’t bother me, lashes are defined and separated, that’s exactly what I’m asking for.

I did not like this mascara. I like big bold lashes but this have me a really bad spider lash effect. It didn’t add a lot of volume or length. It just looked like I had 5 thin lashes.

Product goes on too wet for me. I have to be very careful to apply it or it leaves mascara on eyelids.

Spider legs for daaaays. I tried to love this mascara, I really did, but the way it clumped and made my lashes stiff and spider-y just didn’t work for me.

This was a huge offender in creating spider lashes for me. I am personally not into the spiky lashes look, but I know some are, so give it a try if you are. It also always got on my upper eyelid which was annoying, as was the rose smell.

My quest for the perfect mascara doesn’t end here, I know it’s out there somewhere, but for now (and considering it’s under a fiver), this will do nicely.

Hard to find in the shops, I bought mine on Amazon UK for £4.25 (Free P & P)


  1. October 13, 2014 / 9:59 pm

    mmm where do i begin with mascara! I have now settled for Dior Extase and Lancome Definicils after trying out so many over the years, including drug store. I have long lashes to begin with but believe me, a bad mascara can make my lovely lashes look horrendous. My only real issue with drug store mascaras is that they don’t last 5 minutes before drying out and have tons of perfume in them which may be to mask bad smelling chemicals. I know you should change mascara every couple of months or so but Extase and Definicils give me 6 months of useage and work out excellent value for money.I guess mascara is a very personal thing though and we all have different types of lashes too. Great review though hun x

    • October 20, 2014 / 1:33 pm

      Thanks Mandy.
      I really don’t mind paying out for a decent mascara, such a shame Clarins Be Long flakes so quickly. I’m with you re Lancome’s Definicils (with the skinny brush), but I think they stopped producing the brown shade which is frustrating! Stiletto IS very wet and I can see how it would smudge the upper eyelid if you didn’t wipe excess off the wand, but for now, it’ll do me.
      I’ve also used DiorShow Iconic with the fat brush, but stocks of the brown shade chestnut, are always sold out. I’m off on holiday in a couple of weeks, so might pick up Dior Extase, (like the funky brush) at Duty Free, thanks for the recommendation.

  2. October 14, 2014 / 10:18 am

    Great review, I’m always on the look out for that perfect mascara too, I miss my long thick lashes that I had a few years ago! I shall look for this one next time I’m on Amazon! xx

    • October 20, 2014 / 1:17 pm

      A friend of mine has a very ‘high end’ make up bag filled with Charlotte Tilbury, Tom Ford & Laura Mercier products, but she always use this cheapy mascara – said it was only one to separate her lashes without clogging.
      Also, I’ve got to say it, the RapidLash products really do work on lashes, but they are just so expensive.

Leave a Reply